Friday, December 31, 2010

Happy 2011 From The Global Small Business Blog

And on the first day of the new year, do some productive reading to get your business even more global.  Try:

The Art of the Global Gateway by John Yunker
(Google Books here).

Reach out to the e-world for business.  It starts with web globalization and John Yunker can teach you a thing or two about it.

Best wishes for a happy, healthy and prosperous 2011!

Posted by:  Laurel Delaney, The Global Small Business Blog

2010: Year in (Concise) Review

As my father might say, "Another year shot to hell."

December and Year-End Cycling Wrap-Up

The best thing I can say about this December is that it ended well, with a nice 30-mile ride with the guys (David, Karl, Brian R., and Jonas). The wind from the South was pretty fierce, gusting up over 20 mph, but the expected rain held off, and the temperature rose to a balmy 60 degrees. Unfortunately, it was my first and only outdoor ride in December, which, as anyone who lives in Indianapolis knows, has been a terrible month for cycling. Winter weather came several weeks early this year and did not let up until literally the last day of the month. Total mileage for the month, included indoor rides, was only 120 miles, in part because left knee pain kept me off the bike for a couple of weeks. Total mileage for the year is 4700 miles, down substantially from last year. My crash in early August probably cost me 800-1,000 miles.

My goal for 2011 is to ride longer but not necessarily faster. I enjoy less and less killing myself to keep up with the group going 23-27 mph. I'd rather ride farther and easier. So, I hope to get back above 5,000 miles next year, and maybe closer to 6,000.

See you all on the roads in 2011!

The Most Powerful Force in Business Today: The New Logistics

UPS is sponsoring an international business series over at Small Business Marketing Blog from Duct Tape Marketing and Small Business Trends.

Be sure to check out both places for articles on global small business.

Small Business Marketing Blog from Duct Tape Marketing:
Hidden Challenges Lurking in Global Business

Small Business Trends:
Become a Micro-Multinational Small Business in 5 Steps

Illustration credit here.

Posted by: The Global Small Business Blog

Thursday, December 30, 2010

On This Date

On December 31, 1759, Arthur Guinness signed a 9,000 year lease (that's right, a lease for 9 thousand years) on the St. Jame's Gate Brewery in Dublin, Ireland and began brewing beer. It is no exaggeration to say that it is among the most important events in the history of western civilization.

What I'm Reading Now

Edmund Morris, Colonel Roosevelt (Random House 2010). I found this third and final volume of Morris's magisterial biography of one of our greatest presidents, and one of the most interesting personalities of the twentieth century, under the Christmas tree (or, as I call it, the Hannukah bush). Morris writes with a literary flair that other biographers must envy.






Thomas Mann, Doctor Faustus (Vintage 1999 [1947]). It is a special pleasure of the winter break period to re-read great masterworks. Nearly all of Mann's works would qualify in that category. He is my favorite novelist of any time and place, even though I cannot (I am sorry to say) read him in the original German. This book, which he wrote while in exile (in the US) during World War II, displays Mann's remarkable ability to become truly expert in, and write fluently about, highly technical fields - in this case, musical composition - far removed from his own training and experiences. My version of the book is not that pictured on the left. I have an old, dog-eared edition of the original English translation by H.T. Lowe-Porter.

Bravo Ross Anderson!

Ross Anderson is a Professor of Security Engineering at the University of Cambridge. His student, Omar Choudary, completed a Master's thesis, published (like all other student theses) here at the website of the Cambridge Computer Laboratory. UK banks are unhappy about the public availability of Coundary's thesis because it describes how criminals could foil bank security measures by manufacturing new pin numbers for stolen bank cards. They are demanding that the thesis be removed from university's website on the grounds that its publication exceeds the limits of "responsible disclosure."

To his everlasting credit, Professor Anderson has refused to bow to the dictates of creeping corporatism, writing with great eloquence that the banks "seem to think we might censor a student's thesis, which is lawful and already in the public domain, simply because a powerful interest finds it inconvenient. This shows a deep misconception of what universities are and how we work. Cambridge is the University of Erasmus, of Newton and of Darwin; censoring writings that offend the powerful is offensive to our deepest values."

Chalk up one small victory for freedom of academic expression against the inflated claims of state and corporate security.

The Guardian has the full story here.

Cross-Cultural Learning: Being Able to Shut Up and Listen

Side benefits of learning both a foreign language and a foreign culture.

Snippet:
How to learn about culture and language. When you live in a foreign culture, you learn how to learn. You learn what vocabulary is important, what language learning techniques work, how to make relationships, what skills are important, what details to pay attention to. These skills will carry over to other languages and other cultures in the future.
Read the entire piece here:  The Best Defense (be sure to read the wild comments)

Illustration credit here.

Posted by:  The Global Small Business Blog

On This Date

On December 30, 1853, the US completed the "Gadsden Purchase" of nearly 30,000 square miles of land (about the size of Scotland) in what is now Southern Arizona and Southwestern New Mexico from the Mexican government. It was the final piece of land acquisition in the contiguous United States. Congress ratified the treaty in April 1854.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Wigan 2 - Arsenal 2

Arsene Wenger made 8 changes in the Arsenal side that defeated Chelsea on Monday. That was probably a mistake, as a sloppy, incohesive Arsenal side gave up a late game-tying goal to 10-man Wigan (after N'Zogbia was sent off for head-butting Jack Wilshire). Wigan took an early lead in the match on a questionable penalty call. But Arsenal fought back to take a 2-1 halftime lead. Arsenal's first goal came on an exquisite bicycle kick by the otherwise out-of-form Andrei Arshavin. Arsenal midfielder Denilson, inserted in the starting line-up in place of Monday's man-of-the-match Alex Song, had a very poor match. He was spraying bad passes all over the field, did not work back hard enough on defense. Indeed, his matador-like  defensive technique opened up the Arsenal defense for Wigan's game-tying goal. Squillace also continues to look a very weak link in the center of Arsenal's defense. On the other side of the coin, I thought Rosicky (taking Fabregas's place), Chamakh and Bendtner, all had very good games today. Bendtner scored Arsenal's second goal.

Today's result is a tremendous disappointment after Arsenal's big win on Monday. They had an opportunity to go joint top of the table with Man U and Man City.

Recursive and Self-Correcting Processes in Science

The gang over at Real Climate have posted an instructive piece (here) on how science and scientific publishing work, with special relevance to various climate science controversies and faux controversiesThe blog post infers a set of "lessons" from the controversy that recently erupted over preliminary research, published in the journal Science, claiming, contrary to the conventional scientific wisdom, that arsenic can provide a basis for life. The lessons include the following: 

  • "Major funding agencies willingly back studies challenging scientific consensus."
  • "Most everyone would be thrilled to overturn the consensus. Doing so successfully can be a career-making result. Journals such as Science and Nature are more than willing to publish results that overturn scientific consensus, even if the data are preliminary - and funding agencies are willing to promote these results."
  • "Scientists offer opinions based on their scientific knowledge and a critical interpretation of data. Scientists willingly critique what they think might be flawed or unsubstantiated science, because their credibility - not their funding - is on the line.
The last bullet point is the "key lesson..., and it applies to all scientific disciplines: peer-review continues after publication. Challenges to consensus are seriously entertained - and are accepted when supported by rigorous data. Poorly substantiated studies may inspire further study, but will be scientifically criticized without concern for funding opportunities. Scientists are not 'afraid to lose their grant money.'"

Changing the Norms of Energy Consumption in the US

An interesting article in Scientific American (here) tells about ongoing research at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory to assess how social norms relating to energy consumption might successfully be altered to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. Starting with past success stories of positive norm changes, the researchers hope to identify how hurdles might be avoided and incentives created by policies to alter energy use by individuals. Those past success stories include massive reductions in tobacco use (in 1965, 44% percent of Californians smoked; today only 9.3% smoke) and increased use of seat belts by drivers (see here).

What lessons might those success stories provide for changing norms with regard to energy use? We probably should not be too optimistic. Smoking norms were altered by a massive government information campaign, but that campaigned was facilitated by the large, internal costs of smoking. The increased use of seat belts was spurred, in significant part, by laws prohibiting driving without wearing them. Compliance with those laws was surely facilitated, however, by the internal costs of driving without them. In other words, individual smokers and drivers had substantial personal incentive to stop smoking and to wear seat belts. The same cannot really be said with respect to individual energy consumption. While energy prices obviously create some incentive to conserve, individuals typically do not get sick or die from leaving the lights on. This  is not to say the research efforts are necessarily a waste of time or money. It just means that altering social norms of energy consumption is likely to be more difficult and complicated than getting people to stop smoking or to buckle up in their cars.

How important is increasing energy efficiency to mitigating greenhouse gas emissions and stabilizing the global climate? The answer to that question is somewhat complicated. Simon Dietz of Michigan State University is quoted in the Scientific American story as claiming that, on conservative estimates, decreased energy consumption by American households could result in a 7 percent reduction in total US greenhouse gas emissions, which translates to 1.5 percent of total global emissions. However, Bjorn Lomborg, citing studies of the so-called "rebound effect," notes (here) that energy efficiency improvements do not necessarily lead to nominal reductions in energy use. The economic logic is simple: as energy efficiency increases, the price of energy drops, leading (all else being equal) to increased energy demand. Thus, the key for climate policy is not just to increase the efficiency of energy production or supply, but to actually reduce total energy consumption.

Happy 100th Birthday Ronald Coase

I've recently started noting historical events instead of celebrating birthdays, but I had to make an exception for Professor Coase, especially on his 100th birthday. His birthday is, in reality, an important historical event because of Coase's stature in both economics and legal studies. Two of his seminal articles - "The Nature of the Firm" (1937) and "The Problem of Social Cost" (1960) are among the most widely cited works in both fields. Unfortunately, the later article is too more often cited for the wrong reasons, as both economists and legal scholars continue to misunderstand not only Coase's intention but his analysis (do not read the Wikipedia entry about Coase, unless you want a complete misunderstanding of his work).

Coase was and remains the central figure in the modern Law & Economics movement because he explained why legal rules are such an important component of the economy. The law would not matter if it were costless to use the price system, that is, if transaction costs were zero, because individuals would simply bargain their way around all disputes over entitlements to resources. The reason the law does matter for  economic exchange is that transacting in the market is not costless. Transaction costs are always positive and often quite high. This central insight, while lost on many self-proclaimed "Coasians," who continually cite the "Coase theorem" (so named by George Stigler) and refer to "Coasian bargaining," was the most important combined legal and economic insight of the 20th century.

By the way, the 100-year-old Coase has a new book coming out (co-authored) by Ning Wang, entitled How China Became Capitalist. It will be published by Palgrave Macmillan in June 2011. I wonder how many centenarians have ever published new books?

Watch Out World: Google Is Out To Help Small Businesses Go Global

Google has launched two new services to help small businesses go global:

Google Global Market Finder
Go Global with Google

And I love this statement:

There are 1.9 billion Internet users worldwide. Wouldn’t you like to add them as customers?

Illustration credit here.

Posted by:  Laurel Delaney for The Global Small Business Blog

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Private Property Claims in Parking Spaces on Public Streets

The New York Times has the story (here) of how residents who go through the trouble of clearing snow from parking spaces claim a labor-based, temporary "right" to those spaces, which they mark with orange cones, potted plants, lawn furniture, or just about anything else imaginable. The purpose of the scare quotes in the last sentence is to indicate that the term "right" is being used in a very loose sense; it is not at all clear what party, if any, has an enforceable "duty" not to take the parking space. The "rights" at issue are really in the nature of extra-legal claims based on presumed social norms (or even, dare I say it, natural law).

Are such claims enforceable? Well, according to the New York Times story, in South Boston such claims are legally authorized for up to 48 hours after a snow storm. But it's not clear how strictly that limitation is enforced. In any case, it's doubtful that the claimed right to a parking space could be enforced in a court of law. But such rights often are self-enforced by the claimants, e.g., with threats of slashed tires, broken mirrors, or other acts of retribution, which themselves may be technically illegal, if difficult to enforce. One problem of self-enforcement, of course, is the heightened risk of conflict escalation including the potential for violence.

I don't know of any empirical studies that have investigated the prevalence of temporary private property claims in public parking spaces after snowstorms. Certainly, they have become a normal feature in various neighborhoods in many cities subject to significant snowstorms. It would be interesting to learn just how prevalent the norms are, how they are similar or differ in structure and enforceability from one city (or neighborhood) to another, and what legal acceptance, if any, they have attained in various jurisdictions.  

Arsenal 3 - Chelsea 1

I apologize for not posting this yesterday.

This was a game Arsenal really needed to win - at home to a major league rival - and they did. After a nervous-looking first 15 minutes, Arsenal grabbed the lion's share of possession and were rewarded just before half-time, when Alex Song netted a ball that was deflected in the box after a nice Arsenal move. That goal seemed to give the Gunners more self-belief, and in the first 10 minutes of the second half, they tripled their lead, thanks in part to some poor Chelsea defending. Given that Chelsea have allowed the fewest goals in the Premiership this season, credit must go to Arsenal's offensive pressure for unsettling the usually reliable Chelsea back four. The Gunners two second half goals were scored by Cesc Fabregas (from Theo Walcott) and Theo Walcott (from Cesc Fabregas). Even after Chelsea pulled back a goal from a set piece, Arsenal never looked flustered. They outworked Chelsea, out-muscled Chelsea, and out-played Chelsea.

This could be a real turning point for the current Arsenal line-up, if they build on it and turn out consistent efforts in the coming two weeks, which features tough matches away at Birmingham City and home to Manchester City.

On This Date


















On December 28, 1973, President Richard M. Nixon signed into law the Endangered Species Act. As originally enacted, the ESA sought to protect the existence of endangered and threatened animal and plant species for their own sakes, that is, regardless of their utility to humans and regardless of cost. Though the Act was subsequently watered down to permit the extinction of species in cases where the cost of preservation is deemed too high (by the Endangered Species Committee or "God Squad"), the Act remains a rare example of true environmental legislation (in contrast, for example, to most pollution-control laws, such as the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act, which are primarily public health statutes).

Leaving Your Heart In Argentina

Exploring a new country, buying a vineyard and starting a new life is not the easiest thing in the world to do.

Learn about how a couple pulled it off here:

Moving to Argentina

Illustration credit:  Google Maps

Monday, December 27, 2010

Remembering 2010

PRESIDENT'S CORNER

Norris McDonald

2010 was a very interesting year.  But aren't they all?  This one though, had some very interesting moments.

January included my participation in the Black Enterprise Energy Forum.  EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson could not attend because she was attending the funeral of Vice President Joe Biden's mother.  Deputy Associate EPA Administrator Stephanie Owens substituted for her.

In February, I presented testimony at the EPA Ozone hearing. I also met with the White House Office of Management and Budget on the fly ash issue.

In April, I presented testimony at the EPA hearing on on natural gas hydraulic fracturing.  I also traveled to South Africa from April 4-April13. I attended a White House Great Outdoors Conference at the U.S. Department of the Interior.  President Obama spoke at the conference.  I participated in an environmental justice listening session sponsored by EPA and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.

In May, I was a panelist at the American Association of Blacks in Energy (AABE) annual conference in Columbus, Ohio.  I met Exelon CEO John Rowe and discussed the future of nuclear energy with him.  I presented a statement at the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) public meeting in Buchanan, New York on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the license renewal for the Indian Point Nuclear Power Plant.  I present a statement at President Obama's Blue Ribbon Commission on Nuclear Power. I presented a presentation entitled, "Converting CO2 into Fuel" at the Environmental Justice in America 2010 Conference.

In June, I met with Florizelle Liser, Assistant U.S. Trade Representative, Executive Office of the President.

In July, I gave a statement at the New York Department of Environmental Conservation Cooling Tower Hearing in Buchanan, New York.

In August, I presented a statement at the EPA fly ash hearing. I presented testimony before the National Commission on the Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling.

In September, I visited Port Gibson, Mississippi on the 1st scoping visit for the biomass-to-energy project.  I presented at statement at the EPA greenhouse gas hearing. 

In October, I visited Port Gibson, Mississippi on the 2nd scoping visit for the biomass-to-energy project.

In November, I visited Santa Catalina Island no the 1st scoping visit for a biomass-to-energy project.  I participate as a panelist at the National Black Chamber of Commerce Fall Summit.  We celebrated the Center's 25th anniversary on November 20th.

In December, I visited Port Gibson, Mississippi on the 3rd scoping visit for the biomass-to-energy project.  I participated in a Green DMV home weatherization project in Alexandria, Virginia.

On This Date

On December 27, 1831, the Royal Navy's HMS Beagle left anchorage and headed out of Plymouth Sound on a nearly 5-year journey to survey South America and return via New Zealand and Australia. The ship's captain Robert Fitzroy had her extensively and expensively refitted for the voyage. Having failed to find a friend to accompany him on the trip, Fitzroy asked a fellow captain, Francis Beaufort, to identify a naturalist who might join the venture at his own expense. A young man preparing for the clergy named Charles Darwin filled that role. His  voyage on the Beagle altered his way of thinking about nature and the natural sciences as we know them today (although the later would have changed regardless based on the contemporaneous work of Alfred Russel Wallace and subsequent naturalists).

Steps to Exporting

If you are looking to increase sales and profit, reduce dependence on the domestic market and stabilize seasonal fluctuations with your business, you should consider exporting.

Here are six steps to get you going.

Sunday, December 26, 2010

U.S.A. Perfect Imperfections

3 good things & 3 bad things

Good

1. That we are united from all countries, we're a melting pot, that we are a nation of immigrants who welcome immigrants.
2. That we have many world class universities and free public education from kindergarten through high school.
3. I like that we have freedom of speech and freedom of press.
And like my critical thinking teacher from Guyana said, "Imagine the world without the United States". He said "Regardless if the Democrats or the Republicans win - the country is doing something right."

Bad

1. I don't agree with having immigration quotas in a country made up of immigrants. What's happened is that the English invaded the land of indigenous Native Americans (at least 500 Nations were disrespected, disregarded, displaced & disenfranchised). Then for 100 years there was no immigration policy and the English encouraged immigration to populate the land that they stole. After the English had spread to the west coast they said, "Okay we're good. Let's start excluding people from immigrating now and let's base it on race.
2. The second thing I don't like about the U.S. is that our taxes do not pay for preschool or college tuition.
3. The third thing I don't like is that our taxes do not provide health care for everyone. Our taxes provide free police and fire departments which are essential and even free libraries. The library is of no benefit if you're dead.

On This Date

On December 26, 1776, the US Army won the Battle of Trenton after the daring crossing of the Delaware River in bad weather the night before (see the famous painting below). Two of Washington's detachments failed to make the crossing, but he led the 2,400 soldiers who did make it across on a 9-mile march south to Trenton, where they surprised the mostly sleeping Hessian soldiers. Nearly two-thirds of the (mostly sleeping) 1,400 Hessians were captured, with hardly any losses on the American side. In  numbers, the battle was small, but its importance for the US Army was almost immeasurable. Moral and public support had both been flagging after a series of losses. The victory at Trenton provided a much needed boost to Washington's efforts at recruitment and retention of soldiers.

Saturday, December 25, 2010

Revised Report on Principles & Standards for Benefit-Cost Analysis

Richard Zerbe (Evans School, Washington) has published a revised draft of "Toward Principles and Standards in the Use of Benefit-Cost Analysis." The most significant alteration in this draft, prepared on behalf of the Benefit-Cost Analysis Center at the University of Washington, with funding from the MacArthur Foundation, is that, at my request, my name has been removed from the list of members of the Scientific Committee, who commented on early drafts of sections of the report. I wanted my name removed because, as noted in previous blog posts (here and here), the Scientific Committee did not get to see or comment on the report's recommendations for social discounting prior to publication. Those recommendations struck me as much higher than warranted by the literature, including the various white papers Professor Zerbe commissioned for this project.

All of the white papers can all be viewed here. None of them focuses predominantly on the issue of social discounting; only three of the papers even discuss social discount rates. Importantly, not one of those three papers supports the high discount rates recommended in Professor Zerbe's report. Joseph H. Cook's white paper "On Principles and Standards for Benefit-cost Analysis of Public Health Preparedness and Pandemic Mitigation Policies" finds "considerable agreement in the health evaluation field to use a real discount rate of 3%, and this rate has been codified in several cost-effectiveness guidelines" (p. 20). Lynn A. Karoly's white paper "On Principles and Standards for Benefit-cost Analysis of Early Childhood Interventions," observes the use of discount rates from 3 to 4 percent (p. 27). Finally, the white paper on "Behavioral Economics and Benefit-Cost Analysis" by Lisa A. Robinson and James K. Hammitt recommends hyperbolic discounting, with discount rates that decline over time, in stark contrast to the final report's recommendation of a single, high discount rate.

On This Date

In 1866, in a small manger in South London, the Arsenal Football Club was born. The club joined the Football League in 1893. Since then, the Gunners have won 13 League and Premiership titles and 10 FA Cup championships. They hold the record for the longest consecutive stint in the top flight; and they are the only Premier League team ever to finish an entire season undefeated. Along with Barcelona, Arsenal play the most attractive brand of attacking football - based on close control, passing, and movement - to be seen in the world.

Friday, December 24, 2010

Happy Holidays From The Global Small Business Blog

Best wishes for a happy holiday season filled with warmth, beauty, love and family.

Photo credit:  Laurel Delaney, 12/18/10, Oak Park Avenue, Tinley Park, Illinois, U.S.A.

Posted by:  Laurel Delaney, The Global Small Business Blog

I Support the Cyclists' Boycott of Vail, Colorado

Bikeradar.com has the story (here and here), which sheds an interesting light on the values and decision-making of Eagle County District Attorney Mark Hulbert, who declined to seek a felony conviction against a wealthy Smith Barney financial manager, after he drove off the road and hit a cyclist, causing serious injuries (including bleeding from the brain and a broken spinal cord), and then fled the scene, leaving the cyclist for dead. DA Hulbert allowed the driver to plead to a misdemeanor involving no jail time, allegedly out of concern that a felony conviction might have serious employment consequences for the driver. Very touching, Mr. Hulbert's solicitude for the driver.

In a previous case, the same District Attorney had diligently pursued a felony conviction for "criminal impersonation" against a woman mountain biker for competing in the Leadville 100 bike race on someone else's entry. That woman subsequently lost her job as a school teacher.

The next person who should lose his job is District Attorney Mark Hulbert for making an ass of the law in Eagle County, Colorado.

On This Date

On December 24, 1851, a fire at the Library of Congress building destroyed most of the book collection, including, tragically, two-thirds of Thomas Jefferson's private library of nearly 6,500 books, which Jefferson had sold to Congress in 1815 (for about $24,000) after the library's original collection of 3,000 books was destroyed in a fire started in 1814 by the British army during the War of 1812.

Insights on Doing Business in China

From the Business Pundit:
“We’re really wasting time,” says Janet Carmosky (pictured), CEO of the China Business Network. Carmosky knows what it’s like to be busy. When not running the China Business Network, a resource geared towards international professionals doing business with China; advising major corporations on their China strategies; or speaking at conferences, she writes about China for publications like the Economist and the Harvard Business Review.
Learn more about what she has to say here:

7 Deadly Perceptions About Doing Business with China

Posted by:  Laurel Delaney, The Global Small Business Blog

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Could Still Save Polar Bears

A new study published in the journal Nature (here) reports that the disappearance of polar bears in their natural range is not yet a foregone conclusion. Under business-as-usual models (i.e., no change in greenhouse gas emissions trends), two-thirds of polar bears are expected to disappear by mid-century. However, the authors find that the bears could still be saved by mitigation policies. However, the required mitigation would be substantial and would have to start very, very soon in order to limit global mean temperature increase to 1.25 degrees (Celsius) by 2150.

Given the almost non-existent progress (so far) on mitigation, there is little reason for optimism in the authors'  findings. Indeed, it may take something like the disappearance of the polar bear in its natural range to generate  sufficient political will to start mitigating greenhouse gas emissions.

Understanding Strategic Sourcing

Very rare that I do this.  I have not read this book but stumbled upon it while looking for something else. Why look at the reviews:

Worth buying it!

Great overview of how to leverage the value of sourcing!

Small book with great content!

Easy reading with great content.

A complete guide.

An outstanding supply chain book-must read.

Check it out here:  Strategic Sourcing:  Suppliers Are From Mars, Customers Are From Venus by Murillo Xavier

On This Date...

On December 23, 1919, Parliament in the United Kingdom enacted the Sex Disqualification (Removal) Act, which removed all legal obstacles to women, single or married, from holding civil service offices, becoming solicitors (attorneys), or participating in any other civil profession or vocation.Women had previously been given limited voting rights and been allowed to stand for Parliament.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Wagner, Fisher and Pascual on the Use of Models in Environmental Policy

Liz Fisher (Oxford), Wendy Wagner (Texas), and Pasky Pascual (US EPA) have recently published two articles on the use and abuse of scientific and social-scientific models in environmental policy.

E. Fisher, P. Pascual, and W. Wagner, "Understanding Environmental Models in Their Legal and Regulatory Context," Journal of Environmental Law 22(2):251-283 (2010).
Environmental models are playing an increasingly important role in most jurisdictions and giving rise to disputes. Despite this fact, lawyers and policy-makers have overlooked models and not engaged critically with them. This is a problematic state of affairs. Modelling is a semi-autonomous, interdisciplinary activity concerned with developing representations of systems and is used to evaluate regulatory behaviour to ensure it is legitimate. Models are thus relevant to lawyers and policy-makers but need to be engaged with critically due to technical, institutional, interdisciplinary, and evaluative complexities in their operation. Lawyers and policy-makers must thus think more carefully about models and in doing so reflect on the nature of their own disciplines and fields.
W. Wagner, E. Fischer and P. Pascual, "Misunderstanding Models in Environmental and Public Health Regulation," N.Y.U. Environmental Law Journal 18:293-356 (2010).
Computational models are fundamental to environmental regulation, yet their capabilities tend to be misunderstood by policymakers. Rather than rely on models to illuminate dynamic and uncertain relationships in natural settings, policymakers too often use models as "answer machines." This fundamental misperception that models can generate decisive facts leads to a perverse negative feedback loop that begins with policymaking itself and radiates into the science of modeling and into regulatory deliberations where participants can exploit the misunderstanding in strategic ways. This paper documents the pervasive misperception of models as truth machines in U.S. regulation and the multi-layered problems that result from this misunderstanding. The paper concludes with a series of proposals for making better use of models in environmental policy analysis.
These two excellent articles underscore a point that I have been arguing for a long time: legal scholars and lawyers must approach law-making and law-enforcement processes more like social scientists. This is true not only for administrative processes, such as environmental law-making, but for constitutional interpretation and common-law judging as well. Judges (as judges) rarely, if ever, engage in formal model-building as they seek to "discover" common-law rules and decide cases, but that hardly means they work without models, which, sometimes at least, can be inferred from their decisions. Ultimately, to understand the law, one must try, at least, to understand the models (formal or informal, shared or idiosyncratic) of the participants in law-making and law-enforcement processes.

"Income Disparities In Asthma Burden and Care In California"

According to a new report by the UCLA Center for Health Policy Research entitled, "Income Disparities In Asthma Burden and Care In California," asthma is increasing in California. Between 2001 and 2007, the prevalence of asthma increased significantly and by 2007 nearly five million Californians had been diagnosed with this chronic condition. Although asthma occurs among Californians at all socio-economic levels, it disproportionately affects low-income Californians, who miss more days of work and school, are more likely to have frequent asthma symptoms, and are more likely to go to the emergency department or be hospitalized for asthma care.
Key findings of this report include:

Asthma is widespread and increasing in California

• Lifetime asthma prevalence has increased from 11.3% to 13% between 2001 and 2007 among California adults.
• Current asthma prevalence varies considerably by county, ranging from 6% in San Francisco County to 12.9% in Fresno County (among Californians age 1 and over).
 • Lake, Tehama/Glenn/Colusa, Sutter, Yuba, Contra Costa, Solano, Sacramento, Fresno, Kern, Merced,
Madera and San Bernardino counties all had current asthma rates significantly higher than that of the state.

Asthma disproportionately affects vulnerable Californians

• 8.7% of Californians with incomes below 200% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) have current asthma, compared to 7.8% of those with incomes at or above 400% FPL.
• 31.9% of low-income California adults with current asthma experience asthma symptoms at least once a week compared to just 19.3% of their higher-income counterparts.
• Low-income Californians with current asthma are more likely to be children and people of color.

Asthma impacts productivity of low-income Californians

• Low-income children with current asthma miss more than twice as many days of school due to asthma as higher-income children (2.8 vs. 1.3 days).
• Low-income adults with current asthma miss three times as many work days as higher-income adults (2.2 vs. 0.6 days).

Emergency department visits and hospitalizations due to asthma are higher among low-income Californians

• Among families with incomes below 200% FPL, 18.8% of adults and 23.9% of children went to an emergency department or urgent care facility in the past year because of their asthma, compared with just 8.8% and 12.5% of their more affluent counterparts, respectively.
• Hospitalization rates among low-income Californians with current asthma were more than five times higher than the rates among their high income counterparts (6.5% vs. 1% for adults and 5.8% vs. 1.1% for children).

Low-income Californians with asthma are more likely to be uninsured and lack access to appropriate asthma care

• 22.1% of low-income California adults and children with current asthma were uninsured all or part of the past year compared with 4.4% of higher-income Californians.

• Low-income California adults and children with current asthma are less likely to get an asthma management plan than higher-income Californians.
• Low-income Californians are more likely to have no usual source of care and have difficulty understanding their doctor.

Low-income Californians are more likely to encounter risk factors for asthma exacerbation

• Rates of exposure to second-hand smoke are more than three times as high among low-income Californians with current asthma compared to their higher-income counterparts (13.5% vs. 4%).

(UCLA Center for Health Policy Research, Executive Summary)

So Many Books, Too Little Time

There are too many interesting-looking new books on offer, and I have too little time to read them all. I'm sure this is a problem familiar to many scholars and avid readers. Just now, for example, I want to read:

Pauline Maier, Ratification: The People Debate the Constitution, 1787-1788 (Simon & Schuster 2010)

Edmund Morris, Colonel Roosevelt (Random House 2010)

Autobiography of Mark Twain, Vol I. (Univ. of California Press 2010)

Paul D. Halliday, Habeas Corpus: From England to Empire (Harvard 2010)

Mary Warnock, Dishonest to God: On Keeping Religion out of Politics (Continuum 2010)

Howard Jacobson, The Finkler Question (Bloomsbury USA 2010)

Laura Hillenbrand, Unbroken: A World War II Story (Random House 2010)

John Heilbron, Galileo (Oxford 2010)

I'm sure there are others I'm forgetting. It all makes me want to stop writing and just read.

Thatcherism on Steroids in the UK

I previously posted (here) about the Tory/Lib Dem Coalition's plan to privatize some of the UK's national forest reserve in order to help bring down the public debt. Today's The Guardian reports (here) that the privatization might well include all state-owned English trees. Not even Baroness Thatcher ever contemplated such a thing. I don't know whether Terry Anderson and other "free-market environmentalists" are advising the current UK government, but the idea is a bad one for a whole hosts of reasons, only some of which are addressed in the article.

The article's author John Vidal expresses concern that foreign interests might buy up all the state timberlands and clearcut them for use as renewable energy or to exploit subsurface resources, including coal. At first glance, this seems far-fetched. After all, economic theory suggests that private woodland owners should conserve (not preserve) timber resources to maximize their long-rune economic value. However, as the Canadian economist and mathematician Colin Clark demonstrated in a couple of articles he published in 1973, complete exploitation of a scarce resources might be an optimal strategy under some circumstances. And there is a good deal of empirical evidence, from both the UK and the US, of private timber owners doing exactly what most economists say they would never do. Indeed, the UK's Forestry Commission was founded in 1919 precisely because timber harvesting on private lands was close to denuding Britain of trees.

The forests of largest concern, when it comes to privatization, are those with the greatest public values attached to them, which would surely include ancient woodlands and sites of special scientific interest. For those sites in particular, privatization would likely be a disaster because, even if private owners can be expected to engage in conservation, their conservation decisions will seek to maximize their private utility, not public welfare.

One way that at least some of these concerns might be ameliorated is for the government to issue new regulations on harvesting privately owned timber. However, such regulations would reduce the market value of the timberlands at auction by some uncertain amount, which would be contrary to the government's expressed concern with paying down the debt.

Public opposition to the wholesale privatization of forest reserves is growing. And politics rather than economics will, as always, have the final say. I remain cautiously optimistic that this short-sighted plan to privatize - corporatize would probably be a better word - the UK's entire woodland patrimony will be aborted.

Be Inspired: Open Your Heart and Your Global Paypal Account

My latest contribution over at American Express OPEN Forum via Small Business Trends.

Be Inspired:  6 Places to Donate

Like it?  Then Tweet like crazy!

Photo credit:  Laurel Delaney, lakefront in Rogers Park, Illinois, U.S.A.

Posted by:  Laurel Delaney, The Global Small Business Blog

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Happy 64th Birthday Rick Nielson

The legendary song-writer and guitarist for Cheap Trick. Anyone who was a teenager in the 1970s on the North Shore of Chicago and had an interest in music followed the trajectory of Cheap Trick's career from the clubs in northern Illinois and southern Wisconsin all the way to the world's biggest concert venues.

Instead of showing a  video of a Cheap Trick performance (I highly recommend the series of videos from their Music for Hangovers DVD, available on YouTube), the video below is a little more personal for me. It shows Rick sitting in and playing his song "Downed" with a band led by a guy I knew growing up, Nick Tremulus. At the start of the video, Nick tells a story about one of the best friends I ever had, the late-lamented Kevin Kelly, who was also friends with the guys in Cheap Trick. Nick joined Kevin's band, Rock Service, just after John Osmon and I had left it (John for the Navy, me for college in LA).

Environmental Justice: A Conference Is NOT Making History

PRESIDENT'S CORNER

By Norris McDonald

Over about the past two decades, holding environmental justice conferences have been repeatedly described as historic.  I submit that holding a meeting, forum or conference is not making history.  It is holding a meeting, forum or conference.  On any given day in our nation's capital, there are hundreds of meetings, forums and conferences going on.  History is made when Congress passes a law, the president signs a bill into law or the Supreme Court makes a ruling.  The product of Washington, D.C. is the meeting. So although a meeting, forum or conference includes one of the three actions by one of our branches of government, it is not making history. So can we please stop describing virtually every environmental justice conference as somehow 'making history.' I submit that making history, in an environmental justice context, is passing legislation, preventing a minority community from being polluted, cleaning a site that threatens a community or relocating a community out of a toxic area.

Thankfully, the Environmental Justice in America Conference has not described itself as making history in each of its past four years.  It has provided a venue to address national environmental justice issues on an annual basis.  In essence, this private sector initiative has accomplished standardizing the process for addressing the issue.  The National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (NEJAC) also provides a government platform for addressing EJ issues.  Another government platform is the Interagency Working Group on Environmental Justice.  It is designed to coordinate the federal government response to environmental justice.  There are many entities addressing environmental justice, but there has been very little actual accomplishment, besides meetings, on the ground.

At the recent White House environmental justice conference, activists expressed frustration with the lack of 'on the ground' progress related to environmental justice.    However, without a national environmental justice law, Executive Branch agencies, the Presidential Executive Order on Environmental Justice (12898) and Title 6 complaints are woefully inadequate in addressing environmental injustice.  AAEA is promoting the Environmental Justice Act of 2011 to address these inadequacies.

There is still much work to be done in addressing environmental justice issues.  I hope we can get more actual results 'on the ground' and maybe that will move us beyond considering conferences as making history.

Happy Birthday Frank Zappa (1940-1993)

The one and only.

Import/Export Considerations for Your Global Small Business

Getting involved in international trade is no simple feat.  Here are some import and export issues you will have to understand in order to be successful.

Some Import/Export Considerations

Posted by:  The Global Small Business Blog

Monday, December 20, 2010

Sarah Palin and Environmental Justice

What is Sarah Palin's position on environmental justice?  She does not currently have a 'position' on the issue. So we can only speculate based on her current political philosophy and her positions on other environmental issues.

She is a self reliance Tea Party conservative and she will probably recommend some sort of private sector accomodation between affected communities and the industries identified as their polluters.  She will also make a cold political calculation as to whether she can flank President Obama on this issue (since it involves minorities and low-income people).  Of course, the easy path would be to take the 'low-income' route.  That way the racial component could be removed.  She has to think that she cannot compete with President Obama on the minority front.  We keep hope alive that she would compete though.  Nothing like good old American competition to get results.  Or she could do what some others do and go the Native American route. Or, the Eskimo route might be amenable to her.

But does she believe there is disparate environmental impacts based on race?  That is the core of the environmental justice issue.  And does she believe government has a role in addressing the disparity?  The White House had an environmental justice forum last week and activists participated from all over the country.  However, without a national environmental justice law, Executive Branch agencies, the Presidential Executive Order on Environmental Justice (12898) and Title 6 complaints are woefully inadequate in addressing environmental injustice.  AAEA is promoting the Environmental Justice Act of 2011 to address these inadequacies.  We welcome the support of President Obama and Sarah Palin.

Governor Palin has some things in common with the environmental justice movement.  Both oppose Cap and Trade.  AAEA supports Cap & Trade and is one of the only entitites that has been consistently supportive of the program.  Palin is tough on Big Oil.  The EJ community would agree.  Palin supports alternative energy production (though she promotes all forms of domestic energy production).  That is clearly a position that is consistent with the EJ community.  Palin's family values could lead her to address the disproportionate asthma rates in minority communities. Her support of nuclear power and hybrid electric vehicles are complementary to mitigating smog.  It might not be a bad idea to lure more minorities to Alaska. There is a lot of land and resources up there and many opportunities.  We hope Sarah Palin will take up environmental justice as a cause.

Give us a call Governor Palin.  Todd Palin can give us a call too.  We would be very happy to discuss this issue with you.

Another Reason I Should Live in London

To hear Alfred Brendel. Even though he has (unfortunately) retired from performing, Brendel still gives the occasional lecture. See here.

It Takes Two to Fight a Class War

Those who seek to change rules to redistribute wealth from richer to poorer are often said to be engaging in "class warfare." Such allegations were frequent in the recent fight over extending the Bush tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans (see, e.g., here and here). But isn't it equally class warfare when the wealthy seek changes in the rules to redistribute income to themselves, e.g., through government bail-outs, tax deductions and loopholes, corporate subsidies, lower marginal tax rates, etc?

As Tyler Cowen explained in his recent column in The American Interest (here), income inequality has increased dramatically in the US over the past 30 or so years. The top 0.01 percent of Americans (about 15,000 families) took less than 1 percent of national income in 1974, but 6 percent in 2007. The top 1 percent of earners increased their share of national income, over that same period, from 8 percent to 18 percent. This trend, which has continued through both Democratic and Republican administrations, may be due primarily to market forces as Tyler suggests, but there's no reason to doubt that the wealthiest Americans have both the motivation and the means to fight for institutions ("rules of the game") that promote their own well-being. After all, class warfare is not a one-way fight.

By the way, I'm not convinced that either the increasing income disparities of the last 30+ years or failed efforts to curtail the Bush tax cuts on top income earners really constituted "class warfare," which is really just  a convenient and ideologically-loaded label that substitutes for merit-based arguments about policy choices.

UPDATE: Apropos of the issues I raised, I just came across an interesting column in the New York Times (here), which wonders (implicitly) whether Senator Bernie Sanders, a self-labeled socialist, is more socialistic than the Federal Reserve.

Happy 53d Birthday Billy Bragg

How fitting that Billy's birthday comes just a day after that of Phil Ochs. Both are part of a long folk-music tradition of great songwriters, singers, and political activists. Although I do not share Billy's socialist idealism (I've spent too much time studying real socialist systems to have any idealism about socialism), I admire him greatly as a man and as a musician. Billy is also an occasional columnist for The Guardian. Here is a column he wrote last week in praise of the student protests in UK against tuition increases. Below is the wonderful, sad song "Tank Park Salute" from his 1991 album Don't Try This at Home:

A Checklist for Going Global

Before you take the first step to expanding your business internationally, you might consider the following.

Checklist for going global

And here's another helpful article I wrote in 2006:  Twenty Essential Factors to Consider Before Going Global

Posted by:  The Global Small Business Blog

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Happy Birthday Phil Ochs (1940-1976)

A great folk music composer and singer, who died way too young.

Here is one of his beautiful songs, Flower Lady:

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Mueller and Stewart on the Real Risk of Death from Terrorism

Here, in Foreign Affairs. Excellent stuff. I particularly like the table below, which ranks annual risks of death from various causes, including terrorism.

Butler 83 - Stanford 50

I had never seen a Butler game at home at the Hinkle Fieldhouse, one of the great old college arenas still in use. A friend gave me his tickets for this afternoon's game against Stanford, an alma mater of mine. So, I put on my old, grungy Stanford sweatshirt and headed to the game. I didn't really know what to expect. I had seen a little of Butler this season, enough to know that they have had a bit of a rough start to the season after last year's run to the NCAA final. Stanford I knew even less about, other than the team's 6-2 record, which, given what I saw this afternoon, must have been compiled against a group of high schools. By the middle of the first half, Butler was on top and running away from a Stanford side that was porous on defense and uncoordinated on offense. They seemed poorly coached (with all due respect to Johnny Dawkins). I can't say much about the second half because I left after only 4 minutes of it had passed, when Stanford had not yet scored a point, and Butler extended it's lead to 30 (9 points more than Stanford had scored in the game to that point).

As someone who usually supports Butler as a home-town team, I want to thank the Butler fans for not throwing things at me despite being the only one in the building wearing a Stanford sweatshirt. One of my colleagues who attended the game, who is also a Stanford grad, wore a Stanford hat at the start of the game but replaced it before the end of the first half with a Butler hat. He likes a front-runner.

Happy Birthday Paul Klee (1879-1940)

A great Swiss painter, whose work is easily identifiable, even though it varied from abstract expressionism, to surrealism and cubism. Klee was also a art theorist, who published on the theory of color, and a teacher at the Bauhaus in Weimar.




















Here is Klee's delightful "The Twittering Machine":

A Few Export Questions Answered

Wondering if you can transact international business via fax versus the Internet or how to write an export marketing agreement?  The link below will provide some answers.

Export questions answered:  Export Institute of the United States

Posted by: The Global Small Business Blog

Friday, December 17, 2010

Preliminary Program of the Allied Social Science Associations Annual Meeting

You can view it here. The agenda contains hyperlinks to a fair number of the papers, including this excellent paper by Scott Farrow and Kip Viscusi, which provides a superior starting point for any serious effort to identify "best-practice" standards for Cost-Benefit Analysis.

The Economist on Coase's Theory of the Firm

The Economist, in recognition of Ronald Coase's 100th birthday on December 29th, has published a nice encomium of Coase's revelatory transaction-cost theory of the firm (here). That theory, which went largely unnoticed when Coase first published "The Nature of the Firm" in 1937, eventually gave rise to the modern Law & Economics movement and the development of a New Institutional Economics.

Michael Blake

Michael Blake, 27, is the Associate Director, White House Office of Public Engagement & Deputy Associate Director of the Office of Intergovernmental Affairs.


Michael Blake
Blake worked on the Obama for America campaign, first as Deputy Political Director and Constituency Outreach Director in Iowa and as Deputy Director and Political Director in Michigan. Prior to that, Blake was the Director of External Affairs for the Michigan House of Representatives serving in Michigan Speaker of the House Andy Dillon's cabinet. Before that appointment, Blake successfully co-organized three state house campaigns in the 2006 election cycle.

Blake is a graduate of the Medill School of Journalism from Northwestern University. He is also an alumnus of the Yes We Can political training program in Washington, D.C. He started his political career as an assistant for Illinois State Senator Jeff Schoenberg. (The White House)

Before our white brothers arrived

Before our white brothers arrived to make us civilized men,
we didn't have any kind of prison. Because of this, we had no delinquents.
Without a prison, there can be no delinquents.
We had no locks nor keys and therefore among us there were no thieves.
When someone was so poor that he couldn't afford a horse, a tent or a blanket,
he would, in that case, receive it all as a gift.
We were too uncivilized to give great importance to private property.
We didn't know any kind of money and consequently, the value of a human being
was not determined by his wealth.
We had no written laws laid down, no lawyers, no politicians,
therefore we were not able to cheat and swindle one another.
We were really in bad shape before the white men arrived and I don't know
how to explain how we were able to manage without these fundamental things
that (so they tell us) are so necessary for a civilized society.

John (Fire) Lame Deer

Sioux Lakota - 1903-1976

Posted on

What Are the Legal Requirements to Start an Import Business?

I am working on a new project where I will be covering both importing and exporting for a small business.  Watch for it.  But in the meantime, here's a short cut answer to the question:
The only legal requisites to opening an import business are having an importer of record number, which is usually just the business's tax-identification number, and a surety bond to protect the U.S. government if you can't pay your duties, taxes and other fees. Surety bonds are required for all so-called formal entries where the shipment is valued at more than $2,000, but many importers use them on smaller shipments as well. They can be purchased ...
Read the entire answer:  Opening a Small Import Business

And I am sure there are additional factors to consider.  If they've been left out, please comment.

Arsenal v. Barca

Arsenal have drawn Barcelona in the first knock-out stage of the Champions League. Predicting based on recent form alone, this should be a walk-over for Barca. Arsenal's defense is outmatched by Lionel Messi by himself, let alone the likes of Xavi and Iniesta. While any sensible prognosticator would predict an early exit for the Gunners, the matches should at least be entertaining, featuring two of the world's best, most technically astute footballing clubs.

Happy Birthday Mary Cartwright (1900-1998)

One of the twentieth century's greatest mathematical minds, Mary Cartwright was the first woman mathematician elected as a Fellow of the Royal Society (in 1947), the first woman to serve on that august body's Council, the first woman to receive the Sylvester Medal from the Society for her mathematical research, and the first woman President of the London Mathematical Society (1961-2). She was also Mistress of Girton College, Cambridge from 1949-1968.

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Happy Birthday Ludwig van Beethoven (1770-1827)

No introduction necessary, though people sometimes forget just how revolutionary was Beethoven's work - especially his later work. Audiences in the early 19th century had as much trouble understanding him as audiences 100 years later had understanding Mahler.

Here is my favorite living pianist, Alfred Brendel, and one of my favorite living conductors, Claudio Abbado, in a performance of Beethoven's Third Piano Concerto:

A Revival in Global Economic Activity

Exports during the month hit their highest level since August 2008, the month before the financial crisis.
"More and more of our exports have started going to the faster-growing regions in Asia, Latin America and Canada," said Morgan Stanley economist Ted Wieseman. "It highlights that the emerging markets never really had much of a slowdown at all. They've continued to outperform throughout the crisis."

Exports of industrial supplies were particularly strong, rising 8%, driven by chemicals and plastics. Food exports also surged. Among the big gains: Soybean exports jumped to almost $2.4 billion, an all-time high, from $1.8 billion in September.
Read the entire article here.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

I Prefer OMB's Current Approach to Discounting

Under current rules, the President's Office of Management and Budget (OMB) requires federal agencies to discount streams of future costs and benefits of regulations at alternative 7% and 3% discount rates. The reason for this is made clear in Circular A-4 (see here):
As a default position, OMB Circular A-94 states that a real discount rate of 7 percent should be used as a base-case for regulatory analysis. The 7 percent rate is an estimate of the average before-tax rate of return to private capital in the U.S. economy. It is a broad measure that reflects the returns to real estate and small business capital as well as corporate capital. It approximates the opportunity cost of capital, and it is the appropriate discount rate whenever the main effect of a regulation is to displace or alter the use of capital in the private sector. OMB revised Circular A-94 in 1992 after extensive internal review and public comment. In a recent analysis, OMB found that the average rate of return to capital remains near the 7 percent rate estimated in 1992. Circular A-94 also recommends using other discount rates to show the sensitivity of the estimates to the discount rate assumption.

                                                       *     *     *

The effects of regulation do not always fall exclusively or primarily on the allocation of capital. When regulation primarily and directly affects private consumption (e.g., through higher consumer prices for goods and services), a lower discount rate is appropriate. The alternative most often used is sometimes called the "social rate of time preference." This simply means the rate at which "society" discounts future consumption flows to their present value. If we take the rate that the average saver uses to discount future consumption as our measure of the social rate of time preference, then the real rate of return on long-term government debt may provide a fair approximation. Over the last thirty years, this rate has averaged around 3 percent in real terms on a pre-tax basis. For example, the yield on 10-year Treasury notes has averaged 8.1 percent since 1973 while the average annual rate of change in the CPI over this period has been 5.0 percent, implying a real 10-year rate of 3.1 percent.

For regulatory analysis, you should provide estimates of net benefits using both 3 percent and 7 percent.
New recommendations (here) from the Benefit-Cost Analysis Center at the University of Washington, sponsored by the MacArthur Foundation and authored by Professor Richard Zerbe, make the requirements of Circular A-4  seem almost liberal (something OMB critics could hardly imagine). Professor Zerbe validates  OMB's 7% base discount rate; as noted in a previous blog post (here), he recommends a range of discount rates from 6% to 9% (coming close to OMB's old baseline discount rate of 10%). However, Professor Zerbe recommends using only a single discount rate in any BCA, without the flexibility currently provided in Circular A-4 for alternative calculations using 3% discount rates in cases where the opportunity-cost of capital is less of an issue than present-versus-future rates of consumption.

In Professor Zerbe's view, the opportunity-cost-of-capital approach to discounting is the only correct approach, despite recent work by many other economists supporting consumption-based discounting (which generally implies lower social discount rates).

We can only hope that the MacArthur/Benefit-Cost Analysis Center recommendations on discounting do not influence OMB policy (or policies of similar state-level agencies). Otherwise, the consequences for socially beneficial environmental, health and safety regulations could be severe.